Mini Cooper: Are They Built to Last or Doomed to Fail

Are are mini cooper reliable reliable- A reliability review of the British car brand

This post contains affiliate links, which means we’ll receive a commission if you purchase through our links, at no extra cost to you.Read the Disclosure here.

“Yes” is the short and simple response to the question. Yes Mini Cooper are Reliable cars,  Particularly the second generation and higher models that were released in and after  2014. 

From the time it was originally put into production in 2006 until it was discontinued in 2012, Consumer Reports consistently ranked the MINI Cooper at the very bottom of the dependability rankings. 

There were issues with the primary engine component, the engine cooling system, and the electric system as a whole. J.D. Power came to the same conclusions, which is why they placed the first generation in 28th place out of 32 cars in their dependability rankings.

This does not imply that you should give up your desire of owning a MINI if that is what you want to do; on the contrary, you should not give up your dream. In point of fact, both newspapers came to the conclusion that the quality of the second generation was noticeably better and was a great deal more dependable. 

Both Consumer Reports and J.D. Power have given the MINI above-average marks for reliability since 2015, and J.D. Power has placed it in the number one slot on their list of vehicles ranked according to its dependability.

When it comes to the automobile industry, stigma is a real problem that has to be addressed. 

If consumers identify your brand with a widespread consensus of questionable reliability, then it is going to be a monumental challenge to regain confidence in your company. Because of this, the dependability concerns regarding the MINI Cooper should not be taken lightly.

This is also the situation with MINI. It is general knowledge that BMW acquired MINI in the year 2000 and completely transformed the brand into something very dissimilar after doing so. 

There’s no mistaking it: even the newest MINIs have that unmistakable MINI appearance. 

However, despite being a brand that was initially based upon the unexplained allure and history of its products, MINI devotees unanimously agreed that the new MINIs lacked the essence of the company’s founding principles.

MINI COOPER Reliability

Akin to the original MINI, the new MINI was derived from the MINI Hatch in the beginning, but the company has since branched out and expanded its roster to include a wide variety of vehicles. 

From the well-liked three-door hatchback known as the MINI Cooper all the way up to the crossover vehicle known as the MINI Countryman, whose name is sarcastic.

As is standard practise in today’s automotive business, MINI now manufactures a large quantity of vehicles in order to cover a broad range of territory in the automotive landscape. 

Regardless of how BMW interprets the MINI brand as a whole, the style of each successive generation of the MINI has allowed it to retain its instantly identifiable identity.

In addition, because of the importance that is put on having a modular design, it is accurate to claim that the performance of one model in a contemporary automobile can have an effect, at least to some degree, on the performance of other models. 

As of the time that this page was produced, the primary models that MINI offers are those that can be seen on their official website.


The Suez Canal Crisis of 1956 caused a severe lack of fuel across Europe, which in turn led to an explosion of small, fuel-efficient vehicles across the continent. 

These vehicles included the German “bubble cars,” the Fiat 500 in Italy, and the soon-to-be-released MINI, which made its debut the following year in 1959. 

Their notoriety continued to rise during the 1960s, and they made appearances in movies and shows that were broadcast in the United Kingdom. 

Soon after, people all over the world began quickly associating the MINI with British culture; nevertheless, by the 1970s, the MINI had become unfashionable.

In 1994, BMW completed the acquisition of the brand as part of its merger with Rover Group. 

The following year, in 2002, the MINI Cooper hardtop made its debut in the United States market. 

Not only was it well-liked among younger drivers in bigger cities, but it also garnered a lot of praise from critics. It was honoured with a number of accolades over the years 2003–2010, including the North American Car of the Year award at the North American International Auto Show and the Small Car of the Year award from Top Gear in 2006.

But when they gave their ratings, did they focus on the presentation or the content?

Apply for Auto Loan/Personal Loan and Get your Car faster than you think!

What are the Most Common Issues with the Mini Cooper?

Is the Mini Cooper a dependable vehicle? Discovering the weak points of the Mini Cooper is one approach to answering this question. 

The following is a list of some of the most typical problems associated with the Mini Cooper.

Support for the Front Radiator and a Coolant Hose

Because of their small and height, Minis have a tendency to sit lower than other vehicles and can more readily scrape against curbs. 

Plastic is used for the radiator supports that are located at the front of the vehicle. 

Despite the fact that this makes the Mini lighter, its durability is compromised, particularly when subjected to repeated blows. The radiator supports are susceptible to suffering serious damage if they are bumped even occasionally.

The coolant pipe, which may be difficult and expensive to replace, is susceptible to damage when larger bumps occur.

Water Pump and Thermostat Housing Leaks

The first two versions of the Mini Cooper were plagued by problems with leaky water pumps and thermostat housings. 

Because the housing for the thermostat is composed of plastic, it will ultimately break down due to the cumulative effects of use and abuse over time. 

If your Mini Cooper has around 50,000 miles on it, it is strongly suggested that skilled mechanics repair the pump and thermostat housing. This should be done as soon as possible.

Disabling of the Power Steering System has received many complaints alleging that the electronic power steering of the Mini Cooper is prone to failing, which resulted in BMW ordering a recall for the affected vehicles. 

This issue surfaced sometime around 80,000 miles, and it was determined that either the power steering fluid level was too low or that the electronic cooling fan had failed. 

Notably, owners of Coopers manufactured in 2006 were the ones who lodged the complaints.

Transmission Failure

It was common knowledge that the transmission systems of the first-generation Mini Coopers were prone to breaking down. 

Due to the broad nature of the problem, a lawsuit was brought, which compelled BMW, the company that owns the Mini brand, to offer a guarantee that was tailored to cover the transmission. 

The transmission fluid should not be changed by the owners of the vehicles until it is time to change the transmission oil, as the manufacturer recommended.

If you want to avoid costly mistakes get your car  Get Instant and Fast to read Report here

My suggestion, in the event that you are interested in purchasing a Mini cooper

If you are considering purchasing a high-end luxury automobile, it is in your best interest to perform some investigation before making the purchase. 

Your next step? Vehicle History can provide you with a report. 

There, you will receive all of the information you want from other drivers as well as professionals so that you can make a decision that is completely informed regarding whether or not to forwards with your purchase.

Download  our Luxe car Buying tips Free eBook.

Most Reliable MINI Models You can Purchase

If you are looking to purchase a used Mini Cooper, the following model years are among the most dependable options available.

2006 -2007 Mini Cooper

The Mini Cooper experience is delivered in a package that is exciting, attractive, and dependable by the model year 2006 edition. 

The reliability of the 2006 Mini Cooper received a rating of 4 out of 5 from Consumer Reports, while the customer satisfaction rating received a rating of 3 out of 5.

The version that was released in 2006 had a number of issues, including a lack of power steering and gearbox failures. 

Despite its advanced age, however, if you keep it in good condition, this Mini Cooper will prove to be one of the most dependable vehicles in your garage.

2016-2017 Mini Cooper

The dependability of the 2016 Mini Cooper was rated well by Consumer Reports, earning a score of 4 out of 5. The Mini Cooper earned other high evaluations as well. 

There are three distinct body options available for the 2016 model year: a convertible, a hardtop with two doors, and a hardtop with four doors.

In addition to having an exceptional build quality, the inside of the 2016 Mini Cooper is prettier and more quiet, it has a good fuel economy of thirty miles per gallon, and it handles really well. 

In terms of dependability, newer models of the Mini Cooper are generally superior, but the 2016 version is without question the most impressive.

Least Reliable MINI Models

2005 Mini Cooper

The 2005 Mini was given the “Avoid Like the Plague” mark by CarComplaints, which indicates that consumers should steer clear of purchasing one. 

It has a staggering 927 complaints filed with the NHTSA and four recalls.

The malfunctioning power steering pump in the 2015 Mini is the most significant issue with the vehicle. 

Hundreds of people who filed complaints with the NHTSA stated that the power steering of their vehicle would suddenly stop working while they were driving.

 It should go without saying that this presents a significant threat to public safety and puts the vehicle in danger of being involved in an accident.

Transmission failure is another another issue that must be watched out for. 

The transmission system of the Mini has an average of 113 thousand miles on it, and it sounds like something is scratching inside of it. You should budget around $5,000 to pay for the repairs.

2011 Mini Cooper

The Mini Cooper from 2011 has a lot going for it, such as its outstanding manoeuvrability and remarkable efficiency at the pump (32 mpg). 

The 2011 Cooper, on the other hand, was given the “Never Buy” rating by Consumer Reports because the publication found it to have a number of major flaws.

The primary engine, the engine cooling system, the fuel system, the electric system, and other systems are among the difficulty places. The engine troubles are sufficient justification for avoiding this model year of the Mini Cooper.

2012 Mini Cooper

The Mini Cooper 2012 continued to be a difficult model with reliability concerns the following year. 

The Mini Cooper 2012, which received a score of 1 out of 5 for dependability and customer satisfaction, is similar to the 2011 model in that it has many of the same issues.

2009 Mini Cooper

There were over 300 complaints filed with the NHTSA, and there were three recalls issued for the 2009 Mini. You might want to pass on this model year. 

When started from a cold state, the engine either stalls out or produces a lot of loud noises. This is one of the most obvious dependability concerns with the vehicle.

One user stated that if the temperature is less than 10 degrees Celsius, the vehicle has to be started and let to run for more than ten minutes. 

In addition, when it is trying to start, the engine will emit loud noises that might be very unsettling. 

The condensation that forms inside the batteries is the most likely source of the problem. This may be remedied by using a battery warmer.

Is It A Good Idea To Purchase A Used MINI?

It is a sensible decision to go with a pre-owned MINI on many different fronts. 

The manufacturer is skilled in the art of producing luxurious and technologically advanced automobiles that are also capable of delivering excellent performance. 

In the vast majority of pre-owned MINI vehicles, the journey will be enjoyable and pleasant for you.

In addition, you may obtain the bulk of them for a price that is far lower than what it would cost to purchase the model brand new.

On the other side, you need to be ready to pay the pricey expenses for the upkeep and repairs, so make sure you budget accordingly. 

In the event that something fails, you are going to have to shell out a significant amount of money, particularly if you want the services of an authorised Mercedes expert. 

In addition, you run the risk of having corrosion or rust develop on your luxury vehicle, which is something that no one likes to see. 

If you are looking to buy a used MINI, you should first conduct some research and then thoroughly check the body for any symptoms of rust. 

Always remember to check the area behind the licence plate.

In summing up, we can say that Maserati is not particularly trustworthy. At all. 

Due to the fact that they are exclusive, they do not have the infrastructure for mass manufacturing as many of their other rivals have, which contributes in some way to an improved level of dependability. 

This also means that they are costly to fix, and finding the necessary components may take a significant amount of time and effort. 

Having said that, all of this is included in the deal. 

If you get a vehicle that is of such a high level of exclusivity, then the cost of repairs will be rather high, and the customised nature of the vehicle may cause you to experience complications in the future. 

In the end, though, if you purchase a Maserati, it is not because you are searching for a dependable automobile in which to conduct your monthly grocery shopping. 

You purchase a MINI because it is one of the Cutest and small automobile brands available, in addition to the fact that it looks nice and has incredible performance. 

Apply for Auto Loan/Personal Loan and Get your Car faster than you think!

About Author: James Haines

James Haines is an avid traveler across Australia (mostly on road trips) and a car specialist by occupation. The perfect combo for our cars for road trips

James is a motor mechanic and Luxe Car detailing expert based in Melbourne, Australia.

Know more about the Author